PROTESTERS poured out of Cheshire West and Chester Council's HQ offices after applauding councillors who rejected plans for an alfresco dining area at an award- winning gastro pub.

The application, involving a ground floor veranda with a first floor balcony above, was put forward on land at the side of The Ship Inn at Handbridge which is part of the historic Edgar's Field.

The new build, which was recommended for approval, would take place within a flower bed at the main entrance to the park opposite to a new children's play area, according to a report.

In addition to the Friends of Edgar's Field Park, Chester Civic Trust, the headteachers of four schools and local councillors, objections streamed in from more 500 residents of Handbridge, Westminster Park and Curzon Park, some of whom packed the planning board meeting.

Owners Davin and Sally Harris were present.

There were also letters of support for what is described as the family friendly venue including backing from Rita Waters, the chief executive of Chester Renaissance, who had visited.

Many objectors argued the park was gifted to the people of Chester by the first Duke of Westminster and was subject to restrictive covenants including a ban on the sale of alcohol. It should not be used for private commercial gain.

Objecting, Stephen Rogers for the Friends argued residents were frustrated and angry as they believed the alfresco would be incompatible with the park and the children’s playground.

For The Ship, agent Peter Miller from Chester based MTP Planning pointed many of the objections were not on planning grounds.

Overleigh councillor Arthur Harada (Con), who is also council’s portfolio holder for children services, said one of his main responsibilities was safeguarding children and he believed they would be at risk.

He reminded members of the planning board they each had a corporate responsibility for children.

Cllr Don Beckett (Lab, Winsford North and East) believed the development would have an adverse effect on the conservation area and a negative effect on the park.

Board deputy chairman Cllr Andrew Storrar (Con, Mickle Trafford) suggested that some people would feel improvements to The Ship, which had been closed for a number of years before being refurbished, had enhanced Handbridge.

Cllr Kay Loch (Con, Neston and Parkgate) moved refusal and was seconded by Cllr Beckett.

The board agreed on a 7-1 vote with one abstention to reject the plans.